Left Out In The Cold: A Non-Binary Perspective of The Irish Gender Recognition Bill

TENI Gender Recognition Bill passedToday, the Seanad Éireann voted the Irish gender recognition bill into law. It allows for anyone over the age of 18 to self-determine their own gender, and it has some measure in place for those between the ages of 16-18 to apply for a gender recognition certificate through the courts. It’s far from perfect – there is no pathway available for trans people under the age of 16, the process for those between the ages of 16-18 is arduous, and there is no recognition of non-binary gender.

Despite these drawbacks, the passing of the gender recognition bill (#GRBill) is an historic moment for Ireland. It is the first time legislation has been passed that allows trans people to change their birth certificate in the Irish state.

I want to feel ecstatic about this. Part of me does feel over the moon that my trans brothers and sisters will be getting the recognition they need in order to live life as equal citizens in Ireland. But there’s another part of me that’s sad. I suppose I was hoping that the Irish government would go one step further and legislate for non-binary recognition. I was also hoping that young trans people would be included in this bill. It’s such a pity because Ireland could really have led the way on this front. Although self-determination is an incredible step forward, it feels like so many young trans people and non-binary trans people have been left out again in the cold.

I don’t blame the campaigners, who consistently brought up the issues of lack of inclusion for non-binary genders and young trans people. I blame the legislators, the people at the very top, who stalled and backed away from what would have been an even more significant gender recognition bill than the one that has just been passed.

As a non-binary Irish transgender person, I already feel invisible on a daily basis. The society that I live in isn’t ready to see gender beyond the binary. There’s an acceptance to some extent of those who dress outside of the binary norms, but there’s no social understanding of a person whose gender identity is outside of the box. Cultural acceptance can be seen through the language that we use, and the English language hasn’t yet accepted a third gender.

I know this because I use third person pronouns, but few others use them for me. I know this because I have searched for words that can replace girlfriend as a gender neutral version and have struggled to find one that didn’t imply long-term commitment. I know this because each and every day I am gendered incorrectly – as either female or, less often, as male.

Each time I see legislation passed that is trans inclusive, I try to smile and feel good about it. But until our culture changes, until our use of language changes, until our understanding of gender changes, I will always feel left out in the cold.

This entry was posted in Queer Politics and tagged , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , . Bookmark the permalink.

3 Responses to Left Out In The Cold: A Non-Binary Perspective of The Irish Gender Recognition Bill

  1. I definitely get where you’re coming from. On the bright side, I was at some TENI events yesterday, and it was clear that they’re committed to fighting for nonbinary and youth inclusion during the two-year review period. So there is some hope that this may change for the better soon!


    • Naomhán says:

      That’s awesome to hear, I know that they wanted both included in the first place, so it’s great to know that they’re going to continue pushing for non-binary and youth inclusion!


      • Yeah, they actually held two youth forums on Wednesday (one for ages 14-17, one for 18-25), and they’ll be using those plus survey data to write up a report on what young trans people actually need. Since the forum I attended was ~40% nonbinary, they’ll definitely have a solid basis on which to press for change.


Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )


Connecting to %s